DVD, The Incredible Hulk S1 (Life and Death)
The best thing about this one was seeing Andrew Robinson's name in the opening credits, as he's one of my favourite actors from my favourite TV series ever, 'Deep Space Nine' (he played the Cardassian, Garak). I was thrilled to be able to see a younger version of the man, though I didn't recognise him in the teaser for the episode, it wasn't until he met David (David Barnard this time - he's back to using an alias again!), that I realised the doctor was him - an ironic turnaround when you know Garak's friendship with Dr. Bashir! After the initial excitement of a familiar name, I wasn't sure how the episode was going to go in my estimation, though I hoped it would be one of the better stories of the season. As expected there was no mention of Joanie from the previous episode, and as predicted, Banner just carried on going. This time he's heading for a specific location, Blanchard Metropolitan Hospital, where Dr. Stan Rhodes (named for Stan Lee?), will try an experimental procedure on him to separate his anger gene, or something like that. Unfortunately it turns out Rhodes is rather unethical, as David should have realised when he found out the man was doing this experiment without any kind of permission or proper procedure, so desperate is he for this to work.
I should have guessed Robinson would be playing a bad guy, as that's what he was famous for, but at first Rhodes seems like he cares, his ultimate goal to help people with birth defects, though whether this was his true motivation or it was for money and fame isn't certain, since he was talking to Banner when he said it. But he also shows compassion for the girls that have gone to Matrix, the shady organisation that's buying babies off women that can't afford to look after them, presumably for genetic research purposes. And then we see that Rhodes is willing to murder Banner in cold blood after being cowed by Ellen - she immediately suspects blackmail when she sees a connection between David and Carrie, their newest 'patient,' but I say people that think like that are probably the most likely to practice it and Rhodes would have been held under her thumb if he had backed out of the project. It was effective direction that had Robinson backed into a corner of Ellen's office, and, despite being the taller of the two, his body language and discomfort with the situation leads him to almost crouch in that corner as Ellen stands powerfully over him, an effective shot.
There are other well directed scenes, but there was one technical problem I spotted quite early on: a shot of Carrie Taylor talking to David by the road was spoiled by the juddery camera which was most distracting. Otherwise I liked what they did with the Hulk experiencing the effects of the drug Rhodes gave Banner to kill him, it being so powerful that even the mighty giant has sight blurring in and out, staggering slowly along until his anger leads him to burst out after smashing through the side of a lift (though the shot of him going through a wall looked suspiciously like a reuse of the shot from 'The Final Round' - in the brief instant you see him he's not wearing the shirt he had on). This is the first time we've seen the Hulk really affected by anything - though he's been injured before, the effects don't usually last long, but it took two Hulk-outs (the first a long one), before Banner recovers from the deadly drug. Another first is seeing Hulk smile, which goes a long way to making him into a hero rather than a villain, in line with the sympathetic line they take with him in this series. He's protected women before and tends to react calmly to children, but the baby actually made him happy!
That scene where the police arrive and don't know what to do was good fun, ending with Hulk putting his hands against the wall, as ordered, and the wall being punched out! Again, I wondered if some of that sequence was reused footage from the second pilot 'Death In The Family' as I believe he jumped off a balcony in that also. When we hear that David called Rhodes 'last week' it made me connect this with the '747' episode in which he was trying to make an appointment with another doctor, but they weren't the same people as that one was off to Europe for several months, and more than a week would likely have passed between the several episodes that have happened in between. It's a shame there couldn't be more continuity, but the mention of the places he's been to or just come from are about all we get. That, and McGee poking his nose in! I thought this might be another episode not to feature him, but we get a close call at the end where Banner has to thrust his head into a water fountain at the hospital to avoid the reporter who's on his way to interview Carrie! There is a little continuity in Banner's touching conversation with her when they first meet and talks about the wife he lost, the event that began this whole series off. We also learn that he has, or had, a sister.
It's sad that such scenes are rare in the series as they make the episode more than just action or a familiar story, but in this one we didn't get enough of the personal stuff to improve an otherwise average episode. There was a good stunt when Rhodes is pushed down a flight of stairs (and was far less noticeable a stunt guy than when Banner made the same fall just before, or rolled down the bank near the hospital!), and the idea of showing each hand's changes as he claws his way back up the stairs worked. We also get a rare point of view from the Hulk, as mentioned above, but also during the metamorphosis. The two Hulk-outs both feature a door being taken out, and a wall, but the episode wasn't exciting, being about drugs and medicine in surgery than chases and action, though it did seem to have a social message for those with babies they don't want, talking of aid and assistance for such people. There were also a couple of good lines when Banner sidesteps the question about why he's going to the hospital by saying it's nothing to get worked up about! And then when Carrie says that he's alone, like her, he agrees, sort of, knowing he's never alone with the Hulk inside.
I don't know whether there was a news story about babies being given up or something similar at the time of the episode, but that's the only way I could account for the unlikely added titles on screen when they're dropped off in town at the beginning: 'All characters, organisations, and events in this story are fictional.' That's followed by the place name coming up: 'Marysville, Oregon,' so maybe they were trying to distance themselves from something, or cover themselves, I don't know. I also had a thought for the first time, though I've seen the opening credits so much now - could the deep-voiced narrator telling Banner's story be Lou Ferrigno? I was thinking it sounded like a black man, and then I was thinking Ferrigno must have quite a deep voice, but it remains uncredited. The episode remained rather bogged down, and careful (they feature a conscientious doctor at the hospital to counterbalance Rhodes' malpractice), and either ideas were running low, or funds were, as there aren't the spectacular moments found in some episodes. The writing didn't come to the rescue, so we have another interesting enough story, but nothing more. And I was hoping for so much with Andrew Robinson guest starring!
**